Book Promos,  Book Reviews,  Book Talk,  Mystery & Thriller

Eden Lost – 3.5 Star Book Review

Welcome to one of the April 13th stops on the blog tour for Eden Lost by Andrew Cunningham, organized by Audiobookworm Promotions. Be sure to follow the rest of the tour for audio excerpts, spotlights, and other reviews!

Please note that this post contains affiliate links, which means there is no additional cost to you if you shop using my links, but I will earn a small percentage in commission. A program-specific disclaimer is at the bottom of this post.

About the Book

Eden Lost
Eden Rising Book Two
by Andrew Cunningham

Published 6 April 2014
Page Count: 281

Published 15 January 2021
Narrator: Greg Hernandez
Length: 6 hours and 31 minutes

Genre: Mystery/Thriller
Add it to your Goodreads TBR!

They can’t escape the evil.

When a forest fire destroys their beloved forest sanctuary, Ben and Lila, along with their six-year-old daughter Katie, head west through the earthquake-ravaged landscape toward a rumored thriving community in Yellowstone National Park.

But another rumor persists of a “great evil” in the Midwest – one they will have to deal with if they have any hope of making it safely to Yellowstone, a community they are not even sure really exists.

Six years after finding their peace, Ben and Lila have to reenter the world. Has it gotten better or become far worse?

Amazon US | Amazon CA | Amazon UK | Audible
Try Audible for free!

My Review

My Rating: 3.5 Stars
Consider liking my review on Goodreads.

I was granted complimentary audible access to Eden Lost by Andrew Cunningham as part of my participation in the blog tour for this title with Audiobookworm Promotions. Thank you to all involved in affording me this opportunity! My thoughts are my own and my review is honest.

Eden Lost is the continuation of the Eden Rising story, where in the world’s few survivors of a mass EMP event are learning how to survive and thrive in a post-apocalyptic world where modern technology has been rendered useless. If this sort of survival adventure story is your thing and this second book is what’s immediately available to you, you absolutely can jump in. I have not yet read the first book at the time of writing this review, and I did not feel lost or like I needed to have experienced the initial events of book one to appreciate what was going on.

Ben, Lila and their now six-year-old daughter Katie have been considering finding other survivors for Katie’s sake when a forest fire makes their decision for them and forces them out of their reclusive home. What follows is a long trek across no-longer-relevant state lines as they seek out a community they’ve heard of that has limited power. This trek is full of passing friendly strangers, passing not-so-friendly strangers, dangerous dog packs, and settlements with their own set of politics and opportunities.

I always feel compelled to compare books of this sort with the first novel series in the genre neighbourhood that left an impression on me, and that’s S.M. Sterling’s Emberverse novels (Dies the Fire and sequels.) They both start with a similar concept, EMP or similar events that destroy technology across the world and plunge our modern world back into the dark ages, then follow small groups of people trying to adapt. So far I would say Eden is more pleasant to read in that although the science of the apocalypse isn’t so far out to lunch it’s unbelievable, it doesn’t have the existential dread-inducing gritty convincing realness of Dies the Fire. In other words, Eden hasn’t left me feeling like I’ll have nightmares for a month. I read it, I had fun, I can put it down and move on rather than work through newly acquired trauma.

The psychology of this parents and one small child dynamic in this setting is interesting and well explored, particularly when Ben muses on Lila’s depressive period after a series of injuries prior to the start of this book and how it temporarily changed the parent-child relationship. I would like to point out, however, that I’m not convinced by the mental state presented in Katie. I’m sure the young daughter of a pair of stubborn survivors in the wilderness who’s never known any humans other than her stubborn survivor parents would be quite mature for her age and would have acquired skills we wouldn’t normally require our six-year-olds to learn, but this kid is a 40-year-old woman in a first grader’s body. She doesn’t ask childish questions, ever. She doesn’t point out a random pretty flower or bird as they walk. She doesn’t talk to herself (in a creative play kind of way.) She doesn’t seem to have any comfort items nor is she shown to fidget with anything. (Pebbles? Sticks? Those little wing-shaped twirly things that fall from certain trees?) She’s six! Show me that she’s six! Little birds are cute and wildflowers are pretty and smooth river pebbles are perfect for busy hands. Show me that she’s only recently gained a complex theory of mind and have her confer with one parent about what the other is thinking rather than just presenting her as someone who already has a pretty good idea of what everyone’s thinking at all times. I feel like the most concrete reminder we got that she’s six was Ben’s consideration for how often she would need breaks when they travelled because she’s small. I also felt like some of Ben’s dialogue in particular didn’t feel natural. He tended to make a statement and then elaborate, but Lila and Katie didn’t need the elaboration, it was just exposition for the reader.

The trio ends up temporarily settling down here and there in different communities along their migration path, and the elements of these settlements and choices these people made whenever we reached these stopping points reminded me of my middle-grade fan fiction. I would take kid-lit survival stories like Hatchet and have Brian just choose to stay in the shelter he set up and live there in the woods forever. I remember being asked to write an epilogue in class in grade 7 and I had him collect supplies in the town he was brought back to by his rescuers, peace out and go right back to where he’d been, and construct a cellar. (My teacher wasn’t impressed. She wanted a re-adapting to society type thing.) The details of the settlements along the way in this book remind me of those sort of alternate endings I would write for myself back then. For nostalgia’s sake, for the namaste vibe, I loved that. On the other hand, these scenes were written as brief summaries of work and decisions conducted over several days or weeks, and as such it ended up being a lot of telling rather than showing. I would not have minded more paragraphs if I could have visualized these things happening. I feel like my 13-year-old self could have written those sections exactly, and my 33-year-old self wanted more complexity. The characters got a break and a change of pace whenever they stopped and made a temporary home, but the reader breezed through it and before you know it they’re on the move again. Might as well have just paused for the afternoon.

A lot of this book reads like a travel diary, so take note if that is or isn’t something that appeals to you when considering this book. The narrator is Future Ben’s voice recalling what Past Ben and his little family experienced just a few hours or days ago. It’s passive. The narrative voice is not a separate character and the reader isn’t invited to feel like the fourth human member of this travelling group. That’s not at all an inherently bad thing, but some readers don’t like this kind of more detached storytelling, so I did want to highlight that.

I experienced this one as an audiobook, so I do need to comment on the narrator’s performance. Greg Hernandez has a pleasant voice to listen to and he was able to differentiate between Ben/narrative voice and the quoted dialogue of other characters enough to avoid confusion. Give that this book is all Ben’s perspective it would be easy to lose the other characters’ voices, but that was not the case, and I found it quite easy to follow. I would absolutely pick up other books for the narrator in this case, and I actually checked the Audible listing for Greg’s work just now and added something else to my TBR. 5 star performance!

If you like post-apocalyptic stories, particularly ones that leave survivors in a medieval-type version of the world or books with a lot of travelling, this may be the perfect next read for your list!

About the Author

I’m the author of novels in several genres, including, mystery, thriller, and post-apocalyptic science fiction. Under the name A.R. Cunningham, I’ve also written the Arthur MacArthur series of mysteries for children.

I was born in England, but have spent most of my life living in the U.S.—including 25 years on Cape Cod before moving to Florida. A former interpreter for the deaf and long-time independent bookseller, I’ve been a full-time freelance writer and copy editor for many years. A 4th-degree Master Black belt in Tang Soo Do, I finally retired from active training when my body said, “Enough already! Why are you doing this to yourself?” I’m married, with two grown children and two awesome grandsons. My wife and I spend as much time traveling as we can, and are especially fond of cruising the Caribbean.

​I have been gratified by the response to my books. When I published Eden Rising back in the spring of 2013, I had no idea what to expect. When I sold my first few copies, I was excited beyond belief that someone was willing to take a chance on it. Numerous books and thousands of copies later, I am still humbled by the emails I get from readers telling me that my books kept them up late into the night.

In October of 2014, Wisdom Spring made me an official Amazon Bestselling author, a thrill I never thought would happen. But it still comes down to being able to bring a few hours of escape to a reader. That’s what it’s all about for me.

I hope you will try my books. Please feel free to email me with your comments.

Website | Facebook | Twitter | Amazon | Goodreads

About the Narrator

Author-preferred Narrator of Mysteries & Thrillers

Narrating audiobooks is highly gratifying. I immerse myself into an author’s story in order to bring it to life for the listener. I’ve enjoyed working with Andrew Cunningham for several years. His books are filled with rich characters, and the stories keep me turning the pages.

I also work as a background actor in movies and TV shows.

For more than 20 years, I worked as a radio news reporter and news writer. I spent half of my broadcasting career at ABC News Radio in the Washington, D.C., bureau. I covered all the federal agencies as well as Congress and the White House. I reported on a wide range of stories during my career, including financial and entertainment industry news.

For nearly 24 years, I worked as a federal government spokesman at three separate agencies—National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA), U.S. Mint and Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC).


Tour Schedule

April 84 the Love of Audiobooks
April 9Buried Under BooksJazzy Book Reviews
April 10A Wonderful World of WordsAudiobook News
April 11Nesie’s PlaceI’m All About Books
April 12Bound 4 EscapeThe Book Junkie Reads…
April 13Westveil PublishingSuper Booked!
April 14BookishKelly20202 Girls & A Book

Disclaimer: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Jenna is the artist/illustrator and author behind Westveil Publishing and its sub-banner platforms Jenna Gets Creative and The Westveil Archives. She live in Newfoundland, Canada with her husband, daughter, and feline overlords.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

%d bloggers like this: